By Debby Giusti
Growing up, I loved to read James Michener’s
stories. His books were epic sagas, some more than 1,000 pages long. The
stories spanned generations and traced the history of not only his fictional
characters but also the setting in which each of the stories took place. Hawaii was a favorite of mine, along
with The Source, Centennial, Chesapeake
and Caravans.
![]() |
| The old city gates of St. Augustine. |
Readers today favor shorter reads, and I
daresay most publishers would probably reject a submission as expansive as
Michener’s work. Although if an excessively long manuscript was particularly
engaging, an editor might encourage the writer to cut the large work into a number
of stories that could be marketed as a series.
![]() |
| Shops along the historic district in St. Augustine. |
My husband and I spent last week touring St.
Augustine, Florida, the oldest continuing European-established city in the New
World. With its 453 year history, St. Augustine would be the perfect setting
for a saga or series of stories. I’ll share some of the information I learned, then
let’s brainstorm story ideas and characters who could be featured in a
Michener-like saga or a series of interrelated stories set in the historical
city.
![]() |
| The stones Ponce de Leon arranged in the shape of the cross when he landed in La Florida. |
Juan Ponce de Leon explored the coast of
Florida and went ashore near St. Augustine in 1513. He named the area La Florida after the beautiful flowers
growing there. The local Timucua Indians,
who welcomed Ponce, were thought to get their stamina and strength from drinking
the fresh, crystal clear spring water later dubbed “The Fountain of Youth.”
![]() |
| A statue of Ponce de Leon in front of the Lightner Museum, formerly the Alcazar Hotel. The famed explorer was only 5' 2" tall. |
In 1565, the Spanish monarchy tasked Admiral
Pedro Menendez de Aviles with establishing a defensive post in the New World.
On September 8 of that same year, he landed in Florida and named the area St. Augustine
after St. Augustine of Hippo, whose feast day had fallen a few days earlier. A
Catholic priest traveling with Menendez celebrated Mass and consecrated the
land to God. Following the service, a Thanksgiving dinner was served to the
families and soldiers traveling with the admiral as well as the Timucua Indians,
who warmly embraced the newcomers. Each of the Florida historians with whom we
spoke pointed out that St. Augustine was founded years before Jamestown and Plymouth.
They also boasted that the first Thanksgiving meal took place in Florida.
| The spot where Menendez came ashore and the site of the first Catholic Mass celebrated in the New World |
![]() |
| The Castillo de San Marcos |
In 1672 the Spanish began construction of the
Castillo de San Marcos, a fort made of newly discovered coquina, quarried on nearby Anastasia Island. Made up of shells, the porous coquina withstood cannon fire
and provided a sturdy, fire-resistant fort for the Spanish.
![]() |
| The Oldest House, St. Augustine. Archaeology shows continuous occupancy of this site from the 1650s to the present day. |
The oldest house in St Augustine with
continuous occupancy dates from the 1650s. A fire destroyed the structure in
1702, but it was quickly rebuilt and occupied by the Gonzalez family, who lived
in the two-room dwelling with their ten children. In 1763, Joseph and Mary
Peavett bought and expanded the home and turned the first floor into a tavern
and general store. In addition to running their businesses, Mary was the midwife
in town, and Joseph worked at the military barracks located across from their tavern.
After Joseph’s death, Mary remarried a much younger man who ran through her
money before he died. Mary lived her final years on land she owned outside of
town. Interestingly, Eugenia Price fictionalized her story in the book, Maria.
![]() |
| The Spanish Military Hospital |
![]() |
| A newly developed vice-like tourniquet developed in France clamped off the flow of blood. |
While only 30% of patients survived surgery in
most medical facilities at the time, the Spanish had a 70% to 75% survival rate
due to the sanitary procedures they routinely used. Bacteria had not yet been identified,
but the surgeons washed their hands and instruments between operations. Patients’
soiled clothing was laundered soon after they arrived at the hospital. The
floors were scrubbed with hot water and vinegar, and the mattress tick, or covering,
was washed and the Spanish moss filling burned and new boiled moss inserted for
each new patient.
The apothecary next door stocked horehound and
mustard seed for coughs, white willow bark (from which aspirin is derived) to
ease headaches, cloves for toothaches, rose hips for scurvy and ginger for
nausea. Medicinal herbs grew in the nearby garden, such as comfrey, a
long-leafed plant that looks somewhat like a hosta. The leaves of the comfrey plant
were wrapped around sprained legs or ankles to decrease swelling and inflammation.
![]() |
| The Apothecary. |
In 1819, the Spanish ceded
Florida to the United States, and in 1845 Florida became a state. Fast forward
to the 1880s when wealthy industrialist Henry Flagler, a partner with John D.
Rockefeller in Standard Oil, built the grand Ponce de Leon Hotel in St
Augustine. The very rich wintered there from January to Easter for a sum of
$3,000. Across the street, Flagler built the Alcazar Hotel for middle-class
vacationers. The smaller hotel had a spa, sauna and the largest indoor pool in
existence at that time. Guests of the Ponce could use the Alcazar facilities,
but the less wealthy were not allowed access to the Ponce.
![]() |
| The Ponce de Leon Hotel with its Spanish Renaissance architecture. The hotel was built and decorated within 18 months. |
The Ponce closed in 1967 and is now the home of
Flagler College. The guest accommodations were converted into dorm rooms, and
the students eat in an ornately decorated dining hall where the wealthy in
times past socialized. The Alcazar currently houses the Lightner Museum.
Today St. Augustine is a bustling city with an interesting historic district. Cross over Lion Bridge to Anastasia Island and St. Augustine Beach where the lighthouse—towering 165 feet above sea
level—helps sailors navigate the coastal waters. Constructed in 1874, the first
lighthouse keeper fell to his death while painting the structure. His wife continued
to run the lighthouse for years following her husband’s tragic accident. One of
the subsequent lighthouse keepers and his wife enjoyed entertaining and their
pretty daughters were known to attract the eye of many handsome young men, providing
more fodder for our saga.
![]() |
| The exquisite cupola in the entrance of the Ponce de Leon Hotel, now Flagler College. |
Where should our story begin? At Menendez’s
landing with the families who sailed with him from Spain? Or with the Timucua
Indians who welcomed Ponce de Leon? Should we add a swashbuckling pirate or two
who sailed the coast and came ashore at times to ransack the town?
![]() |
| The St. Augustine Lighthouse. Yes, I climbed the 219 steps to the top. |
Let’s weave the various cultures into an
interesting mix of characters. A Spanish innkeeper’s barmaid who loves a British
soldier. A blacksmith interested in a wealthy landowner's daughter.
![]() |
| The ladies parlor in the Ponce. Edison wired the hotel with electricity and created the ornate clock sealed in the fireplace over the mantel. |
Would the Spanish surgeon at the military
hospital fall in love with his hard working nurse? Or would he have eyes for
the Colonel’s daughter? Shall we include a young woman who longs to apprentice
at the apothecary? Who’s standing in her way? One of the doctors or a suitor who
wants to apprentice as well?
![]() |
| The fountain at the entrance to the Ponce. The frogs form a sundial. The photo was taken at 10 AM. Can you see the sun's shadow showing the time? |
As our saga moves forward, would we include a
woman staying at the Alcazar Hotel who meets a wealthy playboy while strolling
through the park? He is a guest at the Ponce. What happens when he invites the
lovely lady to dine with him at his posh hotel? More than a few eyebrows would
be raised for sure.
![]() |
| More Tiffany glass windows in the Ponce Hotel. Tiffany was a new designer at the time and his work at the hotel brought him much acclaim. |
I’ve only touched on St. Augustine’s rich past
and hope history buffs will provide additional information that could embellish
our St. Augustine saga.
Share your ideas. Anyone who comments will be
entered in a drawing for the fourth and final story in my Amish Protectors
series, AMISH CHRISTMAS SECRETS. The winner will also receive a book about St. Augustine and a small journal.
Wishing you abundant blessings!
Happy writing! Happy reading!
Debby Giusti
AMISH CHRISTMAS SECRETS
By Debby Giusti
Safe Haven for the Holidays
The thrilling Amish Protectors conclusion
Leaving the nursing home where she works, Rosie
Glick’s accosted by a man demanding incriminating evidence her
murdered boyfriend stole—until Ezra Stoltz scares him off. Now
with a killer dead set on
silencing the Amish single mother, Ezra must
hide Rosie and her baby to keep them safe. But can he expose a sinister
conspiracy in time
to save the woman he secretly loves?
Order here!
Watch for
AMISH SAFE HOUSE
Feb 2019
Pre-order here!



















