Erica Vetsch here, and I'd like to talk about author endorsements today. I've been asked recently to provide endorsements for a few projects, and it got me to thinking.
Do you read endorsements? Do they carry much weight? What makes for a good endorsement?
First, what is an endorsement?
An endorsement is a recommendation by someone in the same field or someone with some clout in the arena. It wouldn't do much good for me to write an endorsement for a book on auto mechanics or nuclear fusion. I wouldn't think much of an endorsement by a beautician for a book on the ins and outs of mountain climbing (Unless he/she happened to be a mountain climber.) This is why romance authors endorse books by romance authors and self-help gurus endorse books by other self-help gurus. The endorser is supposed to have some knowledge of the subject matter they are endorsing.
Second, what makes for a good endorsement?
1. As stated above, a good endorsement is provided by someone who has knowledge of the subject matter, and is, hopefully, recognized by the readers of that subject as an 'expert' in that field.
- As always Vetsch brings a setting, her characters, and their love story blazing to life - Mary Connealy, author of Sharpshooter in Petticoats (A Bride's Portrait of Dodge City, KS by Erica Vetsch)
- "A Passion Most Pure is a frolicking read brimming with humor, desire, and addled affections, and guarantees to satisfy the most romantic of hearts."--Tamera Alexander, bestselling author of Rekindled, Revealed, and Remembered (A Passion Most Pure by Julie Lessman)
2. A good endorsement is fairly short. 50-200 words. This is NOT a book review. Succinct, pithy, on-point language is a must. No spoilers, no character studies, nothing that detracts from the book, and nothing that smacks of self-promotion for the one endorsing the book!
- “As always, Ruth Logan Herne shoots straight to the heart with Back in the Saddle…the heart of the story and the reader. This is one cowboy love story you’ll want to enjoy to the very last page.” —Debra Clopton, author of Kissed by a Cowboy (Back in the Saddle by Ruth Logan Herne)
- "Sarah Sundin is a gifted novelist. Bottom line--this book is perfect for lovers of WWII romances and mysteries that would give Nancy Drew a run for her money."--Cara Putman, award-winning author of Shadowed by Grace and Where Treetops Glisten (Through Waters Deep by Sarah Sundin)
3. A good endorsement identifies the audience and/or shows to whom the book will appeal. This might state the genre, or compare the work to that of other authors.
- "Brentwood's Ward unfolds like the best British costume drama, full of rich detail, wit, and intrigue. Readers will fall in love with Nicholas Brentwood from the first chapter. This Bow Street Runner has all the qualities a hero needs: integrity, intelligence, and independence; and the heroine, Emily Payne leads him on a merry chase sure to delight Austen and Conan Doyle fans alike." Erica Vetsch, author of The Cactus Creek Challenge (Brentwood's Ward by Michelle Griep)
- “A story that has it all---mystery, the mafia, and a heroine you can’t help but root for. If Veronica Mars met the Roaring Twenties, you’d end up with The Lost Girl of Astor Street!” Roseanna M. White, author of The Lost Heiress (The Lost Girl of Astor Street by Stephanie Morrill)
4. A good endorsement evokes the hallmarks of the genre. Suspenseful, humorous, quirky. The language of an endorsement is informal and feels like the style of the story being endorsed.
- “Emotionally resonant and brimming with hope, No One Ever Asked is an intimate portrayal of a community in chaos. As Katie Ganshert employs alternating perspectives and vastly different viewpoints, she dives deep into fraught themes of race, adoption, social justice, infidelity, friendship, and more. This gripping story is written with sensitivity and grace, and it will stay with readers long after the final page is turned. A heart-changing, transformative work!”—Nicole Baart, author of Little Broken Things (No One Ever Asked by Katie Ganshert)
- “Across the Blue provides a fascinating insight into the early days of aviation whilst also delving into questions of identity. Readers of sweet romance will enjoy the blossoming relationship between a young man of questionable birth and the young lady of privilege, whose dreams surge beyond societal expectation. Carrie masterfully weaves issues of faith and vivid descriptions into this story of hope and determination, with exciting scenes destined to make your pulse soar!” —Carolyn Miller, author of Regency Brides: A Legacy of Grace series (Across the Blue by Carrie Turansky)
5. A good endorsement includes or at least implies a call to action. There is an encouragement for readers to take a look at the book, to run, not walk, to the bookstore to pick up a copy. A good endorsement urges a reader to join in the fun and experience the same emotions as the endorser.
- "The Huntress of Thornbeck Forest is a wonderful, romantic tale filled with love, betrayal, and forgiveness. I loved this book and highly recommend it to readers of all ages." Cara Lynn James, author of A Path Toward Love (The Huntress of Thornbeck Forest by Melanie Dickerson)
- "Once again Cynthia Ruchti had me falling in love with her characters and not wanting the story to end. From the teenager to the tiny house village people I wanted to follow them on Instagram and read every post. Don't start reading if you need to get up in the morning because this will be an all-nighter." Becky Turner, President KBT Counsulting (Miles From Where We Started by Cynthia Ruchti)
Third, what are some endorsement pitfalls?
One of the major pitfalls of endorsers is doing too many. If you endorse more than a few titles a year, readers will begin to wonder...I receive book recommendations through BookBub, and about twice a month I get recommendations with an endorsement by a best-selling author. Now by his own admission, he reads about a book a day, but if he scatters endorsements like confetti, each one carries a bit less weight with me.
Another pitfall is not reading the endorsements you've done in order to make the new one unique to the story you just read. Not long ago I found two endorsements by the same author for two recent releases, and she called both of them the best suspense she'd read this year. (Insert raised eyebrow.)
Fourth, How do I go about procuring endorsements for my book?
This can be a tough one, especially for a new author, but don't despair. There are many ways to get authors to endorse your book.
1. Look to your author friends, the people you've come up through the ranks with, who know you and your work. You've spent time becoming friends with other writers, and here's where those writers can pay it forward, pay it back, or pay it out.
2. Get your publisher involved. They have other authors in their stable, and they can be called upon to give a possible endorsement to a fellow in-house author.
3. Consider your genre and reach out to authors who write what you do. If they write it, they probably like to read it, so you have a better chance that they might want to read your story for possible endorsement.
4. Tap experts in areas you've researched for your story, or people you've interviewed or questioned along the way. Experts love to be asked their opinion, and if you've got a thriller that involves Homeland Security, and you have a Homeland Security agent as an endorser, it carries more weight!
5. Don't be discourage if your favorite author doesn't say yes. Authors are busy people, and you can't know what commitments and deadlines that author already has. Also, they tend to have lots of author friends with books releasing, and might have filled their endorsement quota for the year. Or they might have obligations to their publisher and a TBR stack that rifles any measly tower in Pisa. It's not personal if they send their regrets.
So, do you read endorsements? Do they carry any weight with you?
Best-selling, award-winning author Erica Vetsch loves Jesus, history, romance, and sports. She’s a transplanted Kansan now living in Minnesota, and she is married to her total opposite and soul mate! When she’s not writing fiction, she’s planning her next trip to a history museum and cheering on her Kansas Jayhawks and New Zealand All Blacks. You can connect with her at her website, www.ericavetsch.com where you can read about her books and sign up for her newsletter, and you can find her online at https://www.facebook.com/EricaVetschAuthor/ where she spends way too much time!
Look what's available for pre-order now!
Journey along in the Old West as four women travel to meet their husbands-to-be and discover that nothing is as it was planned. Eve’s fiancĂ© is in jail. Amelia’s fiancĂ© has never heard of her. Zola’s newlywed husband is dead. Maeve’s travel is misdirected. Can these brides can find a true love match?
The Galway Girl by Erica Vetsch
Kansas, 1875
A mail-order mix-up sends Irish lass Maeve O’Reilly to the Swedish community of Lindsborg, Kansas. Will Kaspar Sandberg consider it a happy accident or a disaster to be rectified as soon as possible?
Kansas, 1875
A mail-order mix-up sends Irish lass Maeve O’Reilly to the Swedish community of Lindsborg, Kansas. Will Kaspar Sandberg consider it a happy accident or a disaster to be rectified as soon as possible?
Coming May 1st, 2019, you can pre-order your copy of Mail-Order Mishaps today by clicking HERE.
Erica, what a well-thought-out post. And thank you for touching on the saying "no" aspects.... I've been delighted to say yes many times, but every now and again I'm just too swamped with work and farm and I know I won't have time to read the book... I feel dreadfully guilty when I have to say no. It is not my favorite word.
ReplyDeleteAnd thank you for including Deb Clopton's endorsement of "Back in the Saddle"! I love that cowboy series and Deb has such a solid hand at both writing and production... she's amazing and she writes great cowboys!
It's hard to say no, but if you want to do a good job with the ones you're committed to, you just have to turn some down.
DeleteDeb is such a pro!
I should also mention that I'm going to go get a couple of these books because these endorsements pulled me in.... So there's an indicator for you!!!!
ReplyDeleteMorning Ruthy! (It's technically still morning here!) Yay for good endorsements pulling you in! Mission accomplished!
DeleteErica, a good post with good nuggets of information. I've only been asked to endorse my crit partner, and I guess I did okay. Fortunately she has other friends, ha ha. I only got up my nerve to ask one person to endorse my Oregon Trail story (besides my crit partner, she has to, I know where she lives). That was Kelly Goshorn, a fellow Pelican author, who only has like 10 minutes to read each day and she spent them on MY book. Plus she said I had "elegant prose," which made my day. Okay, my year. This is one of the Many Ways we can help each other. "A rising tide," blah blah blah. And what fun to read someone else's work! I love reading the books of authors I know. It gives me a glimpse into their hearts.
ReplyDeleteOff to Bible study and errands, may be back later.
Kathy Bailey
Kathy, that's wonderful about getting that endorsement!
DeleteKathy, that's a great way to seek out an endorsement. And Elegant Prose is a lovely turn of phrase in and of itself. I'd be thrilled to find that in one of my endorser's comments!
DeleteWhen I first started reading Christian Fiction (before I discovered all these wonderful bloggers), I used to jot down all the endorsers and read their books, especially if I enjoyed the book that I read. I guess it’s the reverse of what this post focuses on, but I’m still grateful for all the great authors I’ve “met” via endorsements.
ReplyDeleteMindy, I think that's a great way to find authors! I've always thought the ones who get asked to do endorsements must be well known or influential, so they're also worth checking out. :)
DeleteHi, Mindy,
DeleteThat's one of the small rewards of doing a book endorsement. It gets your name out to new readers. :) I'm glad you were able to find so many authors to read through their endorsements!
I don't usually read endorsements. I skim the names in the front. The one time I did pick up a new to me author was when I read an author note at the back of the novel. She thanked her friend and fellow author. I looked up the name of the author and liked the blurbs so I borrowed a book from the library and ended up buying a few of her books. Lee-Ann B
ReplyDeleteLee-Ann, that's a good way to find books, too! Now that you say you skimmed the names from the endorsements it made me realize that I sometimes do that, too. I don't always read the whole endorsement but do look to see who gave it.
DeleteHi, Lee-Ann,
DeleteI often employ the skim-the-name method for endorsements...then, if one catches my eye, I read the entire endorsement. Especially if the endorser is one of my friends. :)
I do read the endorsements and they often convince me to read the book that is being mentioned. I've always admired authors supporting other authors. Thanks for a great post Erica.
ReplyDeleteBlessings!
Hey, Connie! We're all in this journey together, and we all need help and are in positions to give help almost constantly. I love that in CF circles, that help is so willingly and joyfully given.
DeleteYes, I do read endorsements! And if they're by someone whose work I really like, I tend to listen and go try the book they're recommending. I also read reviews when I'm picking out books. So yes, I'm swayed by marketing. :)
ReplyDeleteErica, thanks for the great examples! It helps to see some different types.
I like to read endorsements of the "Big Name" authors, to see who they are recommending, but also who they have recommending their books. It's so interesting to me!
DeleteI do read at least a few of the endorsements. I haven't worked up the nerve to ask for any yet, though. You've got me thinking maybe I ought to. I definitely know a few more authors now than I did when my first book came out. :-)
ReplyDeleteAmy, it doesn't hurt to ask! :)
DeleteHi Erica:
ReplyDeleteThanks for this excellent coverage of endorsements. It seems there is more to them than I would have expected.
I don't place much weight in endorsements per se but I can be influenced by why the book might interest me and this makes the endorsement more like a book blurb by the publisher. In effect, it is what the endorsement says and not so much as to who said it.
Where endorsements do have weight for me is when it is for a new author who is self-publishing and I like the author doing the endorsement. This alone won't cause me to buy the book but it will get me to inspect the book closer.
What I find very influential are the acknowledgements. This is especially true of Medical Romances and crime stories. It has been said that we read fiction so we can lead other lives. Acknowledgements can give some assurance that those other lives are authentic in the background that most interest us.
I also put a lot of weight in a "Dear Reader" letter from the author. The problem here is when this letter is at the end of the book and I don't discover it until I've read the book. I'd like to see "Dear Reader" at the front of the book; however, I can see this feature as a good way to sell the author's next book. And yet they have to be reading the current book before that book can sell the next book.
Do you write "Dear Reader" letters for your books?
Vince
Hi, Vince,
DeleteAll an author can ask of an endorsement or blurb is that it makes a potential reader take a closer look. :)
I wrote Dear Reader letters for my Love Inspired Historicals, and I enjoyed those very much!
Great post, Erica!
ReplyDeleteWhen I was asked to write my first endorsement, I went through my bookshelf and read all the endorsements I could find so I could write one that sounded like I knew what I was doing. Your post would have saved me that trouble! But I learned a lot, and I think the endorsement was acceptable. :-)
Saying no to endorsement requests is also hard. I haven't reached the point where I'm getting too many requests, but I did have a request for a book that I didn't feel like I could endorse (for several reasons.) When another author I respected did endorse the book, I started second-guessing myself. Did she see something in the book that I didn't? Did she even read the book? Was I so far off base?
Your post has made me examine the incident again (this was several years ago,) and I think I was right in my decision. When an author endorses a book, we need to make sure we feel that it's worth our endorsement. Our name is attached to that work, and with our name, our reputation.
If I hadn't already read books by that author I respected, I would be hesitant to read anything by the endorsing author.
It can be a sticky situation...
Jan, I did the same thing when I was first asked for an endorsement...I went to my bookshelves!
DeleteYou're so right. We need to maintain our integrity when endorsing a book. We need to be honest, and in the end, if we read the book and cannot endorse it, we need to abstain.
Which can be so tricky...
Thank you for this post, Erica. I concur with your helpful suggestions. I don't usually read endorsements unless they're on the back cover of the book. Now after having asked for and received endorsements to be placed inside my new novel that will change. I want my readers to also consider the books of these authors too. I'm overwhelmed by the generosity of other writers. I hope if I'm ever asked to endorse a book I will be as gracious. This kind of affirmation means a great deal especially for a new kid on the block.
ReplyDeletePat, isn't it interesting how our perspectives change when we go from reader to author? I look at books differently than I did before I became an author, and now I notice things I didn't know before.
DeleteI agree, Jan, getting endorsements is a sticky situation. Now that I'm on the other side of the published fence I can see how hard it is to get extra books read while one is writing. Not that anyone's asking me for an endorsement at the moment, lol! But, I did approach several romantic suspense authors I admire when I was in the last stages of edits for Northern Deception and received back lovely personal replies as to why the authors didn't have time to do them. I myself would never endorse a book unless I'd read it all the way through and felt I could honestly put my own reputation on the line. And I think with a debut author, it's all the more important that the person doing the endorsement has read the book and made sure she feels comfortable with the subject matter etc.
ReplyDeleteThis was an excellent overview of how to do one as well as how to find someone to endorse you, Erica. Thank you!
Laurie, you're so welcome! Congrats on your book Northern Deception!
DeleteGreat post, Erica. I don't read endorsements. I have written an endorsement for a friend's children's book. It was an honor to be asked.
ReplyDeleteHow nice of you to help out your friend. Did having written one change your approach to whether or not you read them now?
DeleteVery informative post, Erica. I don't usually read endorsements...about books or movies or food! LOL It's all so subjective. But, if someone I trust likes a book I will read it! Happy Monday!
ReplyDeleteI tend to trust book endorsements far more than I trust movie endorsements...isn't that odd? I never thought of that. But I do tend to trust when someone I know recommends something to me...mostly because I can ask questions and refine the recommendation! :)
DeleteSometimes I read the endorsements. I wouldn't put a book back on the shelf because it didn't have one, but I might say, "alrighty then" if it was endorsed by an author I really liked.
ReplyDeleteInteresting post.
Connie, I am often curious as to when a publisher decides to use endorsements and when they don't. Do some authors not need them because they are so successful? Or do the publishers decide to rely only on book reviews for their blurbs?
DeleteI remember one (by Robin Schwarz) because it was endorsed by James Patterson. Night Swimming. The author was new but I thought how cool that he endorsed her. Actually, I liked the book too.
DeleteBTW, I've tried several times in the last few weeks to post on Seekerville but it wouldn't let me. Finally got it figured out! I'm whole again.
ReplyDeleteYay for bending technology to your will! I am tech-illiterate most of the time!
DeleteYes, I read endorsements, usually on author’s who I haven’t read
ReplyDeleteany of their books. I look for endorsements by authors I know.
Hi, Karen, endorsements by authors I haven't read intrigue me, too! :)
DeleteNice post about a critically overlooked topic for authors. I'm soliciting endorsements as we speak for my March release, and I also went to an indie bookstore that tends to sell hundreds of my books. The owner was thrilled to provide me with one.
ReplyDeleteHope, that's endorsement hunting on the smart! The owner is an expert in her field, and she already likes your stuff. Brilliant!
DeleteHi Erica:
ReplyDeleteMore Options!
It occurred to me that you can endorse the book without endorsing the author (it's the only book the author wrote you liked) and you can endorse the author without endorsing the book, (which you have not read) and your endorsement for the book may actually be for another book the author wrote which happens all the time. (You read a great endorsement only to find it's for a different book the author wrote.)
What do you think about using author only endorsements on all your books? Would you need permission each time if the endorsement says something like, "Erica has a beautiful writing voice and wonderfully entertaining style making her one of my favorite authors."
How do you feel when the endorsement was for a different book?
Vince
Vince, this happens often, especially in ABA books. A new book comes out, and in the front, there will be "Praise for Author X's Killer Fiction" and there will be blurbs, endorsements, and or reviews of previous works.
DeleteWhenever you ask for an endorsement, it's good to let the endorser know where their words will be quoted. If it's for a specific book, or if you want to use it on your website or promotional materials, it's good to let that person know.
Interesting post, Erica. I guess I'm more likely to just skim the endorsements. I will have to pay more attention now. I don't suppose it makes a lot of difference on whether or not I read the book. I am probably not reading the endorsements until I have already chosen the book to read.
ReplyDeleteSandy, that used to be me. I might read them later, after I finished the book. Just to see if I agreed with their assessments. :)
DeleteGreat post, Erica, and an interesting topic. You've covered it all...and very skillfully. Thanks! I read endorsements, although I don't necessarily buy the book because of them. Still, they do catch my eye!
ReplyDeleteThank you, Debby! As with most people, I tend to buy a book if I'm interested by the back cover blurb/cover or the author...but, I read endorsements now more than I ever did before.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete