Friday, April 3, 2020

How to Pull the Perfect Story from Imperfect Headlines

A politician once declared "Never let a good crisis go to waste."

That means in times of trouble, or in emergencies, you may have more leverage and opportunity to do things you want to do or to enact things you think are either important or will benefit your constituency.... or your own pocket. :)

Writers are different. Writers see or hear a story and the questions that run through their minds are the "What if?" of a situation... 

What if he doesn't check that rearview mirror as he drives away?

What if she decides to keep the baby and raise her as her own?

What if the house doesn't land on the witch's sister when it sails to Oz?

I've asked several amazing authors to give us ideas for how they winnow stories from headlines. Here's New York Times bestselling author Linda Goodnight's thoughts:


Many of my books are sparked by everyday news stories or a human interest story within a crisis (not the actual crisis). For me, there is no method. I'm sorry. I wish I had ten easy steps, but alas, I am a touchy-feely writer. it's all about how the event or someone in that event makes me feel. Does some portion of the story move me? Will my readers also relate to it on an emotional level? Can I create characters and a book around that kernel of an idea? I am a born fixer, so my desire to create a happy ending for the real people in those news reports gets me searching for a plot that will "fix" the situation (if only in a fictional sense).
The Honey Ridge Novels, for example, all started from one tragic news story of a child missing for many years.  Another time, I heard a news report of a young single mother seeking a family for her children because she was dying. Oh! Can you imagine? I could, at least a little, because that's what writers do. We imagine. I cried for her and those babies, and from that emotion and her unthinkable situation, came the basic premise for the Last Bridge Home. Everything, for me, hinges on the emotion in an event, and then my "what if" mind starts spinning. 

Socially distant hugs from the Okie!




And here is the question posed to award-winning, USA Today Bestselling multi-published author Margaret Daley:


But as an author, how do you pull stories from headlines or crises? Is there a method? Or is it simply inspiration? 

It is inspiration and what I'm passionate about. I've written about human trafficking before but last fall I felt I needed to write another book about what is going on in the US and the world. Missing is about child (sex) trafficking and was one of the hardest books I wrote. There is a lot of it going on, and we need to do something about stopping it.
Take care and stay safe,
Margaret


And USA TODAY Bestselling author Debby Giusti agreed to come on board with her thoughts on this, too.


When I wrote my second book for Love Inspired Suspense, I wove the plot around a nefarious doctor who was harvesting organs and selling them on the black market. Unbeknownst to me, my editor’s father was the head of US organ transplants in the Northeast, and he insisted no such activity could or would take place in the US. As you may have guessed, I had to rework the story. Thankfully, just days earlier, I had watched a news report about folks in the US who traveled to foreign locations where they could not only procure organs more quickly—and cheaply—but they could also have their surgeries done within a few days of their arrival in the country. The travelers were called “transplant tourists” because they often went sightseeing until their organs were available. Soon after surgery, the tourists returned to the US, but without the patients being under a doctor’s care, what seemed like a lifesaver to many often resulted in life-threatening complications. I rewrote my story and included the transplant tourist racket. SCARED TO DEATH released in 2007 and won the Daphne du Maurier Award for Inspirational Suspense the following year.





And then there's my take on this, to wrap it up.

We're not politicians. We don't look at a crisis or a tragedy or a disaster and wonder how we can tip the boat our way...

We look at that situation and think "How can I make this better? How can I fix this?" In my bestselling, award-winning Wishing Bridge series,  I wanted three women with tragic pasts, three old friends, to have to reconvene a dozen years later just in time to re-examine their choices... and I used an unwed mother to do it. It's a tale as old as time, a woman alone, in her hour of need.

People relate to people. We feel for them, and when authors look at a crisis, they don't see dollar signs.

They see hearts and souls.



What are some of your favorite books or series, things that really touched you or stayed with you? Leave a comment below to win a surprise pack of books! 




52 comments:

  1. Good morning, everyone... during this time of crisis, you might not be thinking of books or writing, or your brain may be spinning... and yet, beautiful, poignant stories will come out of all this. Stories inspired by the time, by the events, by the every day people who are affected by this pandemic.

    Lives will change, but the spirit of working together will help us through. I keep thinking the words of a hymn often sung by our choir... "And they'll know we are Christians by our love..."

    Sending blessings to all and huge thank yous to Linda, Margaret & Debby for their words of wisdom today!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Ruthie, for including me in with such amazing authors! Margaret was a mentor in my early years, and I love her stories. Linda Goodnight is an amazing author and her stories always touch my heart! And you know I love everything you write. Color me grateful!

      Delete
    2. Aw, we are a fun bunch, aren't we???? Maybe one of these days we'll all be in the same place again and we can giggle like schoolgirls and eat chocolate!!!!!

      Delete
  2. I like what...all tied up in a neat happy ending! Enjoyed hearing each author's perpective.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Jennifer! With romance stories, there's always a happily ever after! :)

      Delete
    2. I do love happy endings.... I wanted to slap that Sommersby story, why didn't they end up happy????????? SIGH.... :) But I do love a story that's rich in conflict, too, because if life were easy, we'd probably all be shopping at malls... so bringing the hard edges of life to the forefront of fiction really deepens a story for me.

      Delete
  3. thank you, Ruthy. I've jokingly said that during the current hard times I wish I wrote dystopian or post-apocalyptic, but there's nothing wrong with gleaning spiritual lessons from a crisis and shaping them into story. Look at all the great fiction that came out of 9-1-1.
    I don't tend to take things from the headlines because most of my work is historical, but I am always open to being grabbed by an idea.
    One of my favorite series is Teri Blackstock's "Restoration" quartet where an event called the "Pulse" knocks out electronic functions all over the world and people pretty much revert to the Stone Age or at least the 1950s. It is a terrifying picture of what might happen but God's grace shines through in unexpected ways. Worth a read or a reread.
    I'm having trouble with both my landline and my Internet so don't know how long I'll be able to stay on today, or to pop in again. I'll probably spend the day editing my WIP, which is not a bad way to spend a day. My cold is better but it's raining heavily, so I don't want to push THAT envelope.
    May be back later,
    Your Kaybee

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kathy, I've wondered how many manuscripts editors/agents are going to be inundated with over the next year or so that have something to do with a pandemic. I have a feeling very few will be published. First, because the world will still be too raw, like a wound that's barely scabbed, and if it's a present-day setting, it will become dated. Still, I know some writers' minds are awhirl.

      I'm sorry you're having technical issues. Those are the worst. I hate that technology can put us in such a funk when it doesn't work the way it's supposed to. Yet it happens to me more times than I care to count.

      Glad you're feeling better, though. Yes, stay in and stay safe.

      Delete
    2. Mindy, I have wondered how this time of quarantine might make its way into television shows or movies. I know all TV shows have shut down production now, so by the time they get up and running again life will presumably be back to normal. But I am curious how it might get referenced, or could be used in flashbacks for some reason, especially in drama shows.

      Delete
    3. KB, I've been praying for you. I hope you're feeling better in spite of the rain! When the sun is shining, as it is in GA today, my spirits lift! And during this shelter-in-place time, I don't need anything to pull me down. :)

      Remember after 9/11, the stories were mainly feel good reads. No one wanted more doom and gloom. I think that will be the case after this current situation. I'm sure Love Inspired romance stories will be the flying off the shelves. Yes to the pandemic providing good backstory, but I doubt anyone will want to read about what we endured...at least not for a few years to come.

      Delete
    4. BTW, I'm having trouble posting comments. :)

      Delete
    5. Well right now I'm writing a mystery that comes out in March 2021 and I'm referring back to the virus, to the pandemic, to the shut downs as in the past, as 'last year', because that's accurate, but WHAT WILL NEXT YEAR be like? Will there be a vaccine? Will there be a treatment, a version of Tami-Covid? Who knows? And that's tricky because the early books for this mystery series are all in, all set this year, and there won't be a word about the pandemic because we wrote them last summer.... so there's a timeline gap because no one knew, but in retrospect, I'm handling it as if it gets resolved without saying how...

      So that's interesting, right?

      Delete
    6. When they talk about a coronavirus vaccine, and maybe giving it fast to save lives, I always think, Isn't this how the Will Smith movie 'I Am Legend" started?????

      Delete
  4. It's interesting (yeah, it's me again). I just completed and sent in the galleys for the second "Western Dreams" book and I know we're supposed to hate doing galleys, but I was so pleased to be able to do it because it reminded me that yes, this is Not A Dream.
    Living the dream (well, AT LEAST THAT ONE) in New Hampshire

    ReplyDelete
  5. So many books and series have touched me. Currently it is The Heroines Behind the Lines Civil War series by Jocelyn Green. Thank you for sharing your wonderful thoughts. Blessings

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lucy, always nice to hear from you and I'm not familiar with that series... I'll have to check it out!

      Delete
  6. I don't know if headlines give me inspiration, but often a human-interest story does. I saw a story once about a ninety-year-old grandma who loved to play online adventure games and it made me smile so much I put her in a story. The story was trash, but I may use her again somewhere else :)

    Thanks, as always, for inspiration and a smile this morning. Stay well, everyone!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is adorable and you can use her somewhere else. Trust me on this.

      Delete
    2. Glynis, characters like that are always fun because, like small children, you never know what they might say.

      Delete
    3. Glynis, the grandma sounds fun. I doubt she's trash. Have you re-looked the story recently? You might find more there that makes you smile!

      Delete
    4. Hahahaha! I've resurrected some of those great characters and taken them out of terrible early books and tucked them into a story worthy of them, LOL!

      Delete
  7. One of my favorite series is Jan Karon's Mitford series. They're just day-to-day life for Father Tim--the little blessings in shepherding his flock, the little annoyances, the occasional tragedy, loving a good woman, helping souls in need. Karon charmed me from the first page of the first book and reminded me that serving Jesus can happen everyday, everywhere.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That series is a favorite to so many. Good wholesome stories that touch the heart!

      Delete
    2. I love that series.... I knew exactly what I wanted to do when I read that series, gosh... 25 years ago????? Yes, because I was working at BOCES, before I opened my own daycare. Still love it!!!

      Delete
  8. Thanks for being with us today, Linda and Margaret and Debby! Ruthy, great post. I love when we can talk about places to get story ideas.

    I'm with Glynis. I'm not likely to write about headlines but more likely to write about a human interest story I've read. I've got a file of newspaper articles! Gosh, I had forgotten about that file. I think I need to go digging. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You know, I think we're talking the same thing, though... it's not the BIG story of the virus and the Chinese lab and the really ugly bats and loose testing and development and open air markets with weird meat....

      It's the story of the couple on the cruise ship that never come home and their daughter has to reconcile all her angst as she and her sister get together for the first time in years to clear out the house...

      Or the son whose father never came out of ICU and he couldn't say I'm sorry....

      Or the guy who lost his business, and his ex-wife is threatening to sue for custody of their daughter because she promises she'll never, ever, ever do drugs again... the wife, not the daughter.

      So I think we're talking the same thing, that we take the people from the headlines and tell their stories.

      Missy, grab one of those ideas and run with it! I've waited way too long for another Missy Tippens book!!!!

      Delete
    2. That's true, Ruthy! To take those headlines and narrow down closer to the personal level. Good point!

      Delete
  9. Thank you for the post.
    I have read so many books that touched me in different ways. But recently I read Fade to White by Tara K Ross and it left me with a feeling of hope. That God is good and that he is in control

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hope is needed at this current time. Sounds like the perfect book to read during this pandemic.

      Delete
  10. I often play the "what if" game when I see something in the news. But I don't know if I have written anything like that. I really enjoyed the Jan Karon Mitford series as was mentioned above. But my original favorite was Janette Oke. I have all of her books and really enjoyed them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I bought just about all of Janette Oke's books when my daughter was a pre-teen...an advanced reader who needed wholesome stories to read. We both loved Janette Oke's stories!

      Delete
    2. Two great series, for sure..... you ladies have great taste!

      Delete
  11. Hello Everyone. Hope all is well where you are. These are definitely challenging times.

    There have been many series that have impacted me. I love the way the authors take difficult issues and bring love and faith into the stories. A recent series that comes to my mind is Tina Radcliffe's Big Heart Ranch. Siblings who were orphaned and in foster care themselves use their faith and their own experiences to create a safe hone for other orphan and at risk kids. Instead of these characters dwelling on the negatives from their lives, they become positive influences for other kids to break the downward cycle.

    That's a difficult path to walk but definitely a worthy goal to reach for.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Lisa! Tina's stories are always so good!

      Delete
    2. Lisa, that sounds absolutely wonderful! Thank you for sharing it!

      Delete
  12. Hi Ruth:

    Ripping from the headlines gives the writer a layer of instant credibility even before the first word is written. This provides for a welcome start; however, greatness is never found in the idea -- for greatness is always evidenced by the execution.

    The devil is in the details and a devilishly good story takes the familiar on a journey into the interior of surprisingly exciting and inspiring places.

    Your book is a journey. The reader is a passenger and an active tourist. The destination is the goal and is well anticipated. However, it is the trip itself which creates the wonder. This journey might be found in living a different life, traveling through time, being at events which changed the world, or perhaps, just re-experiencing a life-altering romance that has since been dampened by dirty diapers.

    The novel is a magic carpet and the writer is the magician. Write about the ordinary or explore the extraordinary, but make the whole experience an emotional rainbow of memorable delights. What's not to like?

    A book that really touched me and has stayed with me as if it could never leave is, "Talk Before Sleep", by Elizabeth Berg, a book I've read many times. It's a book for me that makes romances and HEAs all the more meaningful…especially in a world being emotionally ripped apart by headlines.

    Vince

    ReplyDelete
  13. Vince, I'm not familiar with that book... I'll have to check it out.

    And this line was wonderful:

    The novel is a magic carpet and the writer is the magician. Write about the ordinary or explore the extraordinary, but make the whole experience an emotional rainbow of memorable delights.

    I'm so glad you stopped by today! Good to see you, my friend!

    And lovely to see what these crazy talented women have to stay about story, about craft... because I know they envision a story like I do, as a unit, not just a bunch of strung-along parts. And there is a big difference to me when a writer can present the story or series as a unit... and not a bunch of parts.

    I think that's where I draw the distinction (for me) between good and great.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The episodic can be like experiencing earthquakes during a hurricane: the power of one is not diminished by the power of the other and, as such, the potential exploitation of the reader's emotions is not to be sneezed at. : ))

      Delete
  14. One thing about ripping stories from the headlines...I love it when an author can take that story and set it in a different place or time. The story of tragedy, or victory, or loss, or redemption is still there. But seeing it against a fresh backdrop makes those original emotions fresh and new. And that brings new meaning to our struggles.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You know, that's so true. Like seeing a tale as old as time told in a modern way, fairy tales come alive, or old stories re-told.

      I was overhearing a show Farmer Dave was watching this afternoon, and a story idea popped into my head... and I could see the kid and his father, and the baseball game....

      And I don't know what it will come to, but the phrase from the show just painted this instant picture of what the book could be like, all on that turn of phrase about a famous athlete.

      The story brain is an interesting thing, isn't it?

      Delete
    2. Jan I so agree. If I read a contemporary suspense, or maybe a Regency Romance and get a "What if" idea from it for another book, it's completely my own by the time I slap a Stetson on their heads and put them on horseback.

      Delete
  15. Thanks for having me on, Ruthy. I'm loving these comments.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thank you ladies for sharing your thoughts and how you glean stories from headlines. I've seen some headlines I think would make a wonderful story, but then that's it. I just think it and do nothing with it. :(
    I think the book that has stayed with me a while is Beth Vogt's Things I Never Told You, a tragic story of losing one's twin sister. The story resonated so much with me because of my own girls - the bond between twins is so incredibly unique and strong. I've never wanted to think that question through - what if? - because I know it would rip my daughter apart and she'd be lost without her sister. It's a beautiful story with a hope-filled message at the end.
    (I'd love to be entered in the draw but understand if shipping costs to Canada are too much...)

    ReplyDelete
  17. I'm digging around, trying to apply this to historical writing. I'm more likely to be struck by an odd character than a news story.
    And of course I heard historical stories and am intrigued by them.
    I'm writing a series right now rooted in the man who founded my town. He was a scoundrel by all accounts. And I wondered what happened to the family he abandoned as he headed on his merry way west.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I have noticed many times that movies come out with oddly similar themes, seemingly unconnected. But surely inspired by something. Like weren't there two meteor-hitting-earth movies a few months apart? And two Volcano movies. Two earthquake movies? (one of them might've been older) But stuff like that happens in odd ways.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I know few books have affected me so profoundly as "A Lantern In Her Hand." It's a Nebraska homesteader farm wife. So maybe that was a connection for me, but wow, I've read it multiple times and it's like, as Abbie Deal ages all her feelings just reflect mine so perfectly in that stage of my life. She had so many beautiful dreams and life was just so overwhelming, five kids, a sod house, a hard life or endless work. All the dreams had to be set aside for the day to day labor.
    And in the end it's like she raised each of her children to live out one of her dreams. And she realized her life, devoid of the high accomplishments she'd aspired to, had been better, more fulfilling, than any dream she'd ever had.
    It makes me want to cry just trying to summarize it.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I have read so many books that really stick with me some have been Tina's books Debby's books love reading about The Amish and Love reading suspens so many great Authors Thank you for the chance to win! Blessings to all

    ReplyDelete

If you have trouble leaving a comment, please "clear your internet cache" and try again. You can find this in your browser settings under "clear history."