Friday, December 18, 2020

How Amish Fiction And Western Historical Are Similar


 

Hello everyone, Winnie Griggs here.
It's just a week until Christmas - where in the world did the month go? Like many of you my Christmas gathering will look a lot different this year and the plans are still pretty fluid. Several family members have tested positive at various times over the past few months - the latest one just this morning.  But I know God is  in control of all that's happening here and in the world at large. So my hope is in Him and in His awesome Love for us.

 

Anyway, a bit of fun news - My first Amish romance, Her Amis Wedding Quilt, released this week! As most of you know, for a little over a year now I’ve been immersed in writing the books in my Hope's Haven series. There will be three books in the series and I'm currently wrapping up book 2. It’s required a ton of research and reading all about this very unique group of people who have their own dialect and mores, but I’ve enjoyed the challenge.

One of the things I learned along the way, however, is that, at least on the surface, there are a number of similarities between Amish fiction and western historicals, the previous genre I wrote in.  Here are several of them

 

The most obvious is, of course the mode of transportation. My previous research into issues such as how to hitch a horse to a wagon and how long it takes a horse and buggy to travel xx number of miles came in handy for sure.

 

Another not-so-surprising similarity is the lack of technology in their everyday life. Although the Amish do make use of some technology they are very deliberate in what they allow into their homes and into their lives. So even though the Amish stories I’m writing are contemporaries rather than historicals, I have to avoid many of the trappings of present day life. Except for very strictly defined exceptions that can vary from district to district – no cellphone close to hand, no television, no computers or tablets. There’s also no electricity but these days many use generators or solar power.

 

Both groups have a strong feelings about the value of close ties to family and community and a belief in neighbors helping neighbors. It’s not unusual to find several generations living under one roof or in close proximity. And you can find several videos of Amish barn raisings, frolics (what they call their gatherings to help an individual in the community with a task) and other tasks.

 

Of course there are lots of differences too. The Amish dialect for one thing. And their strong belief in pacifism. And these book are set in the modern world so even though the Amish themselves don’t make use of all the modern conveniences they interact with those who do and even hire non-Amish to do things like chauffer them to and from places that are too distant for them to travel by buggy.

 


And in honor of this being release week for my first Amish book I’m doing a special giveaway. One of the visitors who leave a comment on this post will be selected to receive a copy of Her Amish Wedding Quilt AND their choice of any of the historical western romance books in my backlist.

 

So leave a comment – are there some similarities I missed? Do you prefer one genre over the other?

Or let’s just talk about Christmas traditions – I haven’t even gotten my tree up yet (yikes!!) but I have taken out the stockings which are my favorite decorations. And there will be a new addition to the crowded line-up on the mantle – my 6 month old grandson. I just need to get out my sewing machine…

 


HER AMISH WEDDING QUILT

An Amish seamstress and a single father have a chance to make a fresh start in this heartwarming first novel of a new series.

Spirited, forthright, impulsive -- everyone told Greta Eicher she'd have to change her ways if she ever hoped to marry. Then her best friend Calvin, the man she thought she would wed, chooses another woman. Now Greta's wondering if the others were right all along. Her dreams dashed, she pours her energy into crafting beautiful quilts at her shop and helping widower Noah Stoll care for his adorable young children.

Noah knows it's time to think about finding a wife. When Greta offers to play matchmaker on his behalf, Noah eagerly accepts. After all, no one knows his children better. But none of the women she suggests seems quite right, because, unexpectedly, his feelings of respect and friendship for Greta have grown into something even deeper and richer. But will he have enough faith to overcome the pain of his past and give love another chance?


Learn more or purchase HERE

 


 

28 comments:

  1. WINNIE!!!! CONGRATULATIONS!!!!!!! I'M SO HAPPY FOR YOU! WELL DONE!

    This is so exciting to see. I brought Christmas cookies to share with everyone... and coffee... Fresh coffee and tea for those who don't drink coffee.

    Good morning, Winnie!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ruthy! And yum! the cookies sound great and thanks for thinking of the tea.

      Delete
    2. Yeah, Ruthy, can you also bring some of the pie you made in Yankee Belle? Tks, KB

      Delete
    3. Tea actually sounds great. Real tea not delicious Ruthy virtual tea. I'll make some and have the virtual Christmas cookies.

      Delete
  2. Winnie, I admire anyone who takes on a new genre. What fun--and yes, a lot of work. I'd love to try something new after I'm more established --mystery, suspense, Amish. Middle-grade dystopian as long as we're dreaming...But I do kind of know where you're coming from. With Western Dreams a wrap, at least for now, I'm exploring another time period and a sort-of other genre, taking a metaphorical baby step from historical romance to historical fiction. After 10 years on the Oregon Trail, I'm making an attempt at Revolutionary Boston. Hope I can pull it off. I live about an hour from the city and an hour and a half from Lexington and Concord, but because of COVID 19 I can't cross the Massachusetts border without quarantining first and after. Hope things open up soon.
    Please enter me in the drawing, I'm getting a little low on TBR snowday reading.
    Kathy Bailey
    Your Kaybee
    Exploring new frontiers in New Hampshire

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kaybee, so cool! Brave even. You go.
      I think a new genre energizes a writer. And if you go back to your other genre you bring that energy back.

      Delete
    2. Hi Kathy. The revolutionary war period is very rich with history and inspiration for a writer. Good luck with your story

      Delete
  3. Her Amish Wedding Quilt sounds wonderful. I am looking forward to reading this book. Thank you for the opportunity to win.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the kind words Emma. And thanks for stopping by

      Delete
  4. Interesting post, Winnie. I can see there are some similarities. I am a little confused about the Amish, though. For example, why is electricity bad but having power from generators OK? I have also wondered why they can ride in another person's car but can't have one of their own. Your book looks good. Please put me in the drawing. And congratulations on your new grandson.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Sandy. Yes, some of the practices can be confusing. My understanding is that they are not against technology per se, but are very mindful of what they allow into their homes based on how it impacts the closeness of family and community. For instance, while owning a car would provide temptation for individuals to spend more time away from family and community, there are times when it's necessary to travel greater distances than is feasible with a horse and buggy. The idea is to put an extra layer between thought and action so it's not a frivolous use. At least that's my understanding

      Delete
  5. I loved this, Winnie. So westerns and Amish? My big stumbling block about ever writing Amish is, I wouldn't get to shoot anybody. That's a big plot device for me.
    And the Amish seems to be thoroughly anti shooting.
    Here's a question, to the Amish hunt? Is that against the rules?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. LOL Mary, there is a very flourishing suspense sub genre of Amish fiction so you could always give that a try. And yes the Amish absolutely hunt.

      Delete
  6. Congratulations on your new release, Winnie!

    It's funny - after a dozen Amish stories, I'm working on a western historical right now. You're right about the similarities!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jan and thanks too for all the times you answered my frantic call for help over some little detail of Amish life. And cool about the western historical. Can't wait to hear more about it

      Delete
  7. Congratulations on your new release!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Well, I had never thought about those similarities before, but I enjoyed your pointing them out. Maybe I'll go pick up an Amish book again. I got burnt out on them for a while. :-) But I never seem to get burnt out on westerns, for some reason.
    Enjoy your holiday season, especially with that new grandbaby.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Amy. And I will absolutely enjoy my sweet little grandson for his first Christmas.

      Delete
  9. Hi Winnie:

    I think the Amish attraction is in that they are the "Other". Amish life acts as a kind of mirror by which we can view our lives as outsiders -- like a fish out of water for the first time.

    Science fiction is largely based on this idea but SF has enormous freedom of story conditions. Amish stories, on the other hand, are very restrictive in what fans expect and will allow. In this respect, I find Regency Romances to be very much like the Amish.

    Regency stories are all about strictures. They are about the times and the ton involving a very narrow and fragile slice of society. They are not about ordinary folks. The time period is very limited. It is a small slice of a much bigger pie -- a world that is not quite real but did exist.


    It always amazes me how authors can keep writing novels given so many restrictions and so many stories that have already come before theirs. I'm reading one of Debby's Amish stories right now which involves microbiology and genetics and the Army CID. Like I said, amazing.

    In a way, Tony Hillerman also had an Amish 'look and feel' with his Navajo stories. Hillerman generated a sub-genre because he took so long between novels that other writers jumped in to fill the gaps. The Navajo society was also a 'mirror' to view our lives as outsiders. The Navajo have their own values and ways which are admirable, as are the Amish ways. They have their own language and a simple way of life on the reservation.

    I'm looking forward to reading your take on Amish romances. A new author to the field is always welcome! It's like playing a new golf course for the first time. There is lots of promise and anticipation. May you find great success!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Vince, Thanks for those very kind well wishes. And yes, I've always mentally compared the Amish genre with the Regency genre - they both have very specific and rather narrowly defined reader expectations and a special dialect.

      Delete
  10. Your new story looks delightful, Winnie! I loved the blurb!

    I enjoy writing about the Amish world and am sometimes amazed at how easily I can step into that environment. Not that I would want to live without electricity and phones in real life, but the Amish way of life makes a great setting for books.

    I'm still finishing up on decorating and wondering whether to send cards this year. Not much news...stayed home, wore masks when shopping at the grocery, survived thus far. :)

    Merry Christmas!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Debby. And you're way ahead of me. I haven't put up the one bit of Christmas decor yet other than to display the Christmas cards we've received. Thankfully my two youngest daughters are coming by tomorrow to help me put my tree up

      Delete
  11. I think Amish and any historical are similar for the exact reasons you mentioned (especially the horse transportation!). I prefer Amish over western historicals. I used to steer clear of the Amish genre but now it's my favorite!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think another similarity is that couples may not marry for love but for the need. For example, a widower may need a mother for his children, or visa versa.

    Congratulations on you new venture.

    wfnren at aol dot com

    ReplyDelete
  13. I Love reading the Amish books and this one sounds amazing Thanks for the chance to win Merry Christmas to all!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Merry Christmas and Congratulations on your new release. I’m looking forward to reading as it sounds fascinating to me.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Have a Merry Christmas I have read you book in the love inspired historical and found you now on this blog post
    Anxious to read more of your books

    ReplyDelete

If you have trouble leaving a comment, please "clear your internet cache" and try again. You can find this in your browser settings under "clear history."